Tuesday, June 05, 2007
Posted by The Dean of Cincinnati
Dear Tom Callinan:
As Vice President of Content, I thought you may wish to take a closer look at your paper’s sports content, especially as it looks like your paper is guilty of plagiarism. I am writing this letter because I would like to know (1) The Enquirer’s policy towards plagiarism, and (2) how your paper responds to allegations that a recent sports column crossed the line.
Mark Curnutte’s Sunday column was called “NFL Insider”—yet all of its content appears to have been taken from other news sources. This was recently documented by a blog named “Cincy News Ache,” which claims that your paper is “the worst newspaper in the United States.”
Here is the totality of :
The Enquirer’s NFL writer, Mark Curnutte, is an NFL insider. Says so right on his Sunday column, NFL Insider.
Apparently, all you need to do to be an “insider” is read the web sites of other newspapers, because that’s all Curnutte is doing in putting the column together. Each item was reported somewhere else first. The Brady Quinn item was reported by Cleveland area media (the Plain Dealer and the Warren Tribune Chronicle) midweek. The item about the Pittsburgh Steelers’ search for a new center was in Saturday’s Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, and has been reported before. The item on Samari Rolle of the Baltimore Ravens was reported by the Baltimore Sun on Friday. The item on Buffalo Bills’ ticket sales was reported by the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle on Thursday.
And the item on St. Louis Ram Marc Bulger? Curnutte writes:
Bulger, 30, said he tries “to stay out that stuff” when it comes to contract talks.
The St. Louis Post Dispatch wrote on May 26:
Bulger, 30, said he tries “to stay out of that stuff” when it comes to contract talks.
Curnutte dropped the word “of” in the partial quote, but otherwise it’s the same sentence.
At the end of the NFL Insider column, the Enquirer is thoughtful enough to put this tagline: “Written, in part, from notes provided by other NFL beat writers.”
In part? I would say that 100% is a big part, and not a single item is properly attributed to its original source. Writing “Rolle ... told reporters who cover the Ravens” is totally inadequate. There doesn’t seem to be a shred of original reporting here, and it even appears Curnutte has engaged in a little cutting and pasting.
Every sports writer does this, re-reporting for readers in one city something previously reported in another. Attribution rules are always a little loose. But you should never pass off others’ work as your own. Putting your picture on a column of old news and calling yourself an “insider” takes this to a very high level.
It appears this blog post has done some solid work documenting this “insider’s” totally unoriginal reporting. And it seems to have crossed the line into plagiarism.
That is why I made those two requests above. Please clarify your policy on plagiarism and providing credit to source materials.
Thank you,
The Dean of Cincinnati
cc: Barbara Henry, Gannett Senior Newspaper Group President
Mary Kay Cabot, The Plain Dealer
Mike McClain, Warren Tribune Chronicle
Ed Bouchette, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Jamison Hensley, Baltimore Sun
Sal Maiorana, Rochester Democrat and Chronicle
Bill Coats, St. Louis Dispatch
• Share This Article!
Listen to this article
Help The Cincinnati Beacon Grow! Participate in Social Networking!
Members
Register
Tell us what you think!
Anonymous comments are allowed, but you can log in above to stamp your name and to avoid typing the anti-spam code.
|